Cindy's Story Part 2
Last New Years Eve Cindy and I decided to go to Atlantic City . The drive from our house was a couple of hours . We made reservations for a package deal . You get a room , a show ,dinner and breakfast for a couple hundred dollars . We arrive and check in the afternoon and take a quick nap. Then decide to gamble a little before we dress for dinner and the rest of the night . While in the casino a woman walks up and starts rubbing my shoulders as I sit in front of a poker machine with Cindy sitting next to me . The woman asks if I'm ready to go back to the room . As I start to tell her to she has the wrong person I hear Cindy say to her " Peg , Why are you groping my husband ?"
The woman it turns out is a teacher from Cindy's school . Peg looks at me and starts giggling," Cindy , Your husband is a dead ringer for my boyfriend . I'm sorry , he's down here gambling and I wanted tell him its time to get ready ." We were both going to the same show so the women decided we would meet and go together .
We went and dressed . I wore a suit and tie while Cindy wore a black tuxedo coatdress . Cindy made sure that when she sat in the chair to put her heels on I could see enough of her leg to tell that she was wearing a garter belt and stockings . Cindy had her hair and her makeup done very nice , she looked very sexy . We went to meet Peg and her date , Tony .
Peg is a year or 2 older than my wife about my age or so and very cute , brown hair brown eyes with glasses that add a little sex appeal to her overall appearance . Peg's body isn't half bad either , she has a great ass and she wore a silk jumpsuit that showed off her ass beautifully . When we met Tony we immediately understood Peg's mistake earlier .Tony and I looked like brothers ,we even had the same hair cut , same height and build . To make it even more ironic our suits would have been identical except his was black where mine was dark blue . We went to dinner and it was apparent Tony must have been a big gambler because we didn't have to wait in line . They sat us at a booth next to the stage and dance floor . We had a good dinner and got along well with each other .
Our waitress thought Tony and I were twins and the women kept looking from me to Tony then back as if to find a difference . The show opened with a comic and he made a few jokes at our expense thinking we were twins . He kept telling Cindy and Peg not to make love with to us with the lights out because we would probably switch partners when we got bored and then they wouldn't know which of us to sue for child support . The band came on next and played until a few minutes before midnight then the champagne and noisemakers came out for the countdown . The band started to rock while the four of us danced and partied .
Peg had a little too much to drink and was so ***** that Tony needed our help to get her to the room .She kept saying " Tony thanks for a great night or are you Ron .I can't tell anymore ?"before giggling uncontrollably . We got her to the room and it wasn't really a room it was a luxury suite . Tony explained earlier that he came here quite a bit and the casino comped him the room . He told us to come in and see it . We went in and Peg insisted we have a drink with her in that annoying way that some drunks have of insisting when it is the last thing they need . She wouldn't take no for an answer so we had a drink . Tony went to the bar in the suite and opened a bottle of champagne that I know costs a few hundred bucks a bottle . Peg sat in a chair and kept laughing about the comic joking about leaving the lights on when we make love , saying she would have to because she would never be able to tell the difference between me and Tony in the dark . She asked Cindy if she thought she could tell the difference . Cindy said "Of course I'd know which one was my husband ." Peg started snoring in the chair and Tony carried her into bed then returned . The 3 of us started having a discussion of how Cindy thought she would be able to tell the difference so easily . We finished the bottle and Tony opened another . Cindy at this point was rather tipsy but nowhere near the shape that Peg had been in .Myself and Tony weren't feeling any pain either . Cindy was explaining that she knew how I kissed and how my lips felt . I was a little skeptical and told her so .
" OK , hotshot I'll prove it . I'll kiss both of you with the lights out and then tell you which is which " she challenged me . I said lets try it . We tried turning the lights out but it was too dark to move without walking into something with the drapes closed and not dark enough with them open . We finally settled on a making a blindfold for my wife out of a linen napkin and left the television on for light so Tony and I could move around to keep her from knowing which was standing where . Cindy sat on the couch blindfolded while Tony and I went into the bedroom then one of us went to the couch and kissed my wife while the other waited at the door watching . I went 1st and kissed Cindy ,trying to kiss a little bit differently than normal .Then Tony went . It was strange watching my wife kissing someone else . I felt a surge of excitement from it . Tony as agreed upon walked to the bedroom door after the kiss so Cindy wouldn't have any help . She thought I was the 2nd kisser . We laughed and told her she was wrong . Cindy made an excuse saying she didn't kiss long enough . We said we will try it again and she should take her time . I went 1st again and Cindy was really kissing passionately this time ,fingers through my hair , biting my lips all the little techniques I have felt many times before . I'm thinking this time she knows and she is just making me think she is going to kiss both of us like this to get even at me for laughing at her . She breaks the kiss and I get up with a huge erection .
I notice that Cindy's dress had slid up a little and the tops of her stockings are peeking out of the slit below the last button on the dress . Tony goes in for round 2 and I think Cindy is going to give him a peck on the cheek and say Ok games over . Instead she starts kissing Tony in the same manner as she just kissed me . Tony is returning her kiss with a vigor . Finally they come up for air . Cindy triumphantly and confidently picks wrong again . Cindy defiantly crosses her arms and says " Are you sure ?" and when we assure her that we were she suggests we try again but standing with our arms around her this time . I'm starting to enjoy this a bit . It was something new and exciting sharing my wife with another man even though it had only progressed to a few kisses but I kept wondering how far I would want it to go never mind how far Cindy would allow it to progress . I also knew that when Cindy had a few drinks in her she would argue that she was right even when anyone else could see she was wrong about anything that happened to catch her interest . This was starting to look like one of those times ,she wasn't about to admit she was wrong .
Tony whispered to me " Is you wife really wearing a garter belt ?" I lied softly " I don't know , maybe, I'll see if I can feel through her dress this kiss . Give it a shot yourself she will probably think its me . "
Tony gaped " You sure ,I don't want to make anyone uncomfortable ?" to which I just nodded before Tony approaches Cindy for the next kiss .
Cindy wraps her arms around Tony as they kiss and begins moving her hands around his back and shoulders . I realize she is trying to cheat . She trying to guess which one it is by feeling his body . Tony starts to return the favor by moving his hands to Cindy's waist then down her butt trying to feel the garter belt that I knew was there . I could also see from my vantage point that their crotches were pressed together . I knew Tony had to be as stiff as I was and I had the feeling that all this kissing was having an effect on my wife . When they finally broke the clinch Cindy had a self satisfying smile that told me she was going to guess wrong again. As I moved closer to my wife I noticed that her face was flush and I peeked at her cleavage which I knew gets the same rosy color when she is really turned on . In the low light I couldn't be certain but it appeared to be the same color as her face . I embraced my wife and kissed her deeply . I tried as best as possible to mimic Tony's hand movement from a moment earlier . I knew from a few slow dances earlier this evening that if I held Cindy close I could feel her lacy undergarments pressing through her dress.
During one of our dances she had described them as sexy and lacy and informed me that she was wearing a bra and panties with the garter and hose without a slip . I considered that Tony had just felt what I had felt . I also noticed that Cindy was softly grinding her pubic area against my hard cock . I wasn't sure if she even knew she was doing it . We broke the kiss and Cindy picked correctly this time but before Tony could say anything I held my hand up for him not to speak and then I told her she was wrong again . And then I added that she was cheating by using her hands to help her guess . She started to protest then made a complete about face saying " Well hands are okay to use because that is part of kissing and anyway the whole question was about sex . I use my hands during sex why wouldn't I be able to use them now ?"
Tony jumped in ," Are trying to get help from our clothes ? We could take them off but then you might be able to tell from a scar or mole or something ." I picked up that line of reasoning by saying " Cindy wouldn't be able to tell that way anyway ,look how long she's been trying this way and she 's missed every time ." Cindy still blindfolded stunned me by replying " Well then take 'em off then if you think I can't do it . I can't see you anyway if your naked or almost naked what difference is it going to make to me ?"
Tony and I went to the bedroom where Peg was still snoring loudly . I told Tony I wanted to see how far Cindy would go with this . I think he realized I was getting off on watching him and my wife so he just listened and nodded when I told him to try moving his hands up her dress . I told him I was going to go first to see if I could loosen her dress up . Cindy was standing when I walked across the room naked with a hard-on leading the way . We started kissing standing up and I pushed her onto the sofa . We kept kissing with our tongues exploring each other's mouths . My dick was pressing against her stocking clad thigh and I moved my hand down on the pretense of moving my member to a more comfortable position when I really wanted to unbutton the one buttoned that held the dress closed . I accomplished that then noticed a 2nd button on the inside of the dress . Cindy was running her fingers through my hair while we kissed and I moved my hand up her legs to see if she would stop me or not . She didn't .I was able to unfasten the last button and her dress slid open revealing her body in a matching red and black lace bra and panty set with a matching garter belt . Cindy looked sexy as hell with her flat stomach and 34 C chest ******* . She had one leg hooked over the top of the sofa while the other rested on the floor .She just lay there not saying a word as I left the sofa Tony took up where I left off . He kissed Cindy and his hands glided right to her tits .
Cindy moaned softly and I just stood watching from 3 feet away as Cindy's hand grasped Tony's prick . Tony took this as the greenest light he has ever seen . He moved his kiss from Cindy's lips to her nipples popping her tits out of the bras cups as he did so .
Tony moved one hand down and slid Cindy 's panties to the side ******** her glistening pussy . I knew from Cindy's moaning and wriggling that there was no going back at this point . Cindy was gasping " OHH that feels so good " Tony slid a finger into her cunt and Cindy jumped and shuddered with a small orgasm . Cindy guided Tony's dick to her pussy and Tony eagerly entered her as I watched . Cindy wrapped her legs around Tony's waist and locked her ankles together . It wasn't too much longer until she was using he feet to push Tony forward into her .
Cindy was commanding him to " FUCK ..ME... HARDER.." I started to jerk off and felt my self starting to come just as Tony started to thrust harder and Cindy was humping him back . I came all over Tony 's arm and Cindy's tits as Cindy arched her back and started to cum while Tony pulled out and came on my wife's stomach a moment after I did .
Tony climbed off my wife and stood up next to me . Cindy took the blindfold off and looked at both of us ,unsure .She came to me and kissed me softly saying Happy NEW Year then did the same to Tony . I got dressed and we left . Tony had promised me he wouldn't saying anything especially since he didn't want Peg to find out . The next day as we drove home Cindy told me how exciting it was for us to make love in front of a stranger and when I said I watched not Tony she looked at me in stunned silence . It then hit me that she thought it was me she was fucking while Tony stood watching . I told her how exciting I found it watching her having sex with another man . Cindy was silent the rest of the way home and I kept thinking this is going to be a big problem . When we arrived home no sooner did I close the door then Cindy was all over me . We made love right on the floor inside the front door . I think Cindy was trying to see if she could tell any difference between now and last night . She started to ask if I though she was a slut or a dirty whore as we made love . The dirty talk was turning me on and answered that I enjoyed last night tremendously . After we finished we talked about it further and I convinced her it was all right . She felt guilty for picking wrong and thought I was mad . I didn't tell her until much later on that I had pushed Tony towards her the whole time .
Cindy kept her head down and nervously drained her glass as she finished the story for Tina's benefit . Tina in an awestruck tone exclaimed " Wow ,is that smoking . What a night . And you husband didn't have a problem with it .You are so lucky ." Surprised Cindy replied " What do you mean ? " " Well your husband gets turned on watching you hump other guys ,you should make him happy . Think about it , You have this great marriage with all the stability and other things that go with it yet you can have this hedonistic secret life with your husband's complete blessing . You can have your pick of hunks down here and Ron won't be here for a few more days ,you should take advantage of it . I know I'm I am . I haven't had a good roll in the hay in a couple of months ."
" You think I should do it ?" , Cindy asked . " Women cheat on their spouses all the time . Its exciting , dangerous and you have permission . What happened after you got home that New Years ? " Cindy went on to describe how we both started to fantasize about having a threesome . We would go to a restaurant or even at the mall and when either one of us saw a guy that looked like a candidate we would start tell each other what the guy would do to Cindy and where it was happening ,a motel ,the backseat of the car ,things like that . Cindy and I would usually make love that night and we would flesh out the fantasy during the lovemaking . When Cindy once asked why I didn't join in when Tony was fucking her , I told her I was afraid she would freak out .
After this Tina prodded Cindy ," I bet the reason you were so hot while fucking Tony was that you weren't sure whether it was Ron or Tony . You at first thought it has to be Ron but then I bet deep in the back of your mind you kept thinking how decadent it would be if it was really Tony and not your hubby. " That set Cindy's mind whirling.
Last New Years Eve Cindy and I decided to go to Atlantic City . The drive from our house was a couple of hours . We made reservations for a package deal . You get a room , a show ,dinner and breakfast for a couple hundred dollars . We arrive and check in the afternoon and take a quick nap. Then decide to gamble a little before we dress for dinner and the rest of the night . While in the casino a woman walks up and starts rubbing my shoulders as I sit in front of a poker machine with Cindy sitting next to me . The woman asks if I'm ready to go back to the room . As I start to tell her to she has the wrong person I hear Cindy say to her " Peg , Why are you groping my husband ?"
The woman it turns out is a teacher from Cindy's school . Peg looks at me and starts giggling," Cindy , Your husband is a dead ringer for my boyfriend . I'm sorry , he's down here gambling and I wanted tell him its time to get ready ." We were both going to the same show so the women decided we would meet and go together .
We went and dressed . I wore a suit and tie while Cindy wore a black tuxedo coatdress . Cindy made sure that when she sat in the chair to put her heels on I could see enough of her leg to tell that she was wearing a garter belt and stockings . Cindy had her hair and her makeup done very nice , she looked very sexy . We went to meet Peg and her date , Tony .
Peg is a year or 2 older than my wife about my age or so and very cute , brown hair brown eyes with glasses that add a little sex appeal to her overall appearance . Peg's body isn't half bad either , she has a great ass and she wore a silk jumpsuit that showed off her ass beautifully . When we met Tony we immediately understood Peg's mistake earlier .Tony and I looked like brothers ,we even had the same hair cut , same height and build . To make it even more ironic our suits would have been identical except his was black where mine was dark blue . We went to dinner and it was apparent Tony must have been a big gambler because we didn't have to wait in line . They sat us at a booth next to the stage and dance floor . We had a good dinner and got along well with each other .
Our waitress thought Tony and I were twins and the women kept looking from me to Tony then back as if to find a difference . The show opened with a comic and he made a few jokes at our expense thinking we were twins . He kept telling Cindy and Peg not to make love with to us with the lights out because we would probably switch partners when we got bored and then they wouldn't know which of us to sue for child support . The band came on next and played until a few minutes before midnight then the champagne and noisemakers came out for the countdown . The band started to rock while the four of us danced and partied .
Peg had a little too much to drink and was so ***** that Tony needed our help to get her to the room .She kept saying " Tony thanks for a great night or are you Ron .I can't tell anymore ?"before giggling uncontrollably . We got her to the room and it wasn't really a room it was a luxury suite . Tony explained earlier that he came here quite a bit and the casino comped him the room . He told us to come in and see it . We went in and Peg insisted we have a drink with her in that annoying way that some drunks have of insisting when it is the last thing they need . She wouldn't take no for an answer so we had a drink . Tony went to the bar in the suite and opened a bottle of champagne that I know costs a few hundred bucks a bottle . Peg sat in a chair and kept laughing about the comic joking about leaving the lights on when we make love , saying she would have to because she would never be able to tell the difference between me and Tony in the dark . She asked Cindy if she thought she could tell the difference . Cindy said "Of course I'd know which one was my husband ." Peg started snoring in the chair and Tony carried her into bed then returned . The 3 of us started having a discussion of how Cindy thought she would be able to tell the difference so easily . We finished the bottle and Tony opened another . Cindy at this point was rather tipsy but nowhere near the shape that Peg had been in .Myself and Tony weren't feeling any pain either . Cindy was explaining that she knew how I kissed and how my lips felt . I was a little skeptical and told her so .
" OK , hotshot I'll prove it . I'll kiss both of you with the lights out and then tell you which is which " she challenged me . I said lets try it . We tried turning the lights out but it was too dark to move without walking into something with the drapes closed and not dark enough with them open . We finally settled on a making a blindfold for my wife out of a linen napkin and left the television on for light so Tony and I could move around to keep her from knowing which was standing where . Cindy sat on the couch blindfolded while Tony and I went into the bedroom then one of us went to the couch and kissed my wife while the other waited at the door watching . I went 1st and kissed Cindy ,trying to kiss a little bit differently than normal .Then Tony went . It was strange watching my wife kissing someone else . I felt a surge of excitement from it . Tony as agreed upon walked to the bedroom door after the kiss so Cindy wouldn't have any help . She thought I was the 2nd kisser . We laughed and told her she was wrong . Cindy made an excuse saying she didn't kiss long enough . We said we will try it again and she should take her time . I went 1st again and Cindy was really kissing passionately this time ,fingers through my hair , biting my lips all the little techniques I have felt many times before . I'm thinking this time she knows and she is just making me think she is going to kiss both of us like this to get even at me for laughing at her . She breaks the kiss and I get up with a huge erection .
I notice that Cindy's dress had slid up a little and the tops of her stockings are peeking out of the slit below the last button on the dress . Tony goes in for round 2 and I think Cindy is going to give him a peck on the cheek and say Ok games over . Instead she starts kissing Tony in the same manner as she just kissed me . Tony is returning her kiss with a vigor . Finally they come up for air . Cindy triumphantly and confidently picks wrong again . Cindy defiantly crosses her arms and says " Are you sure ?" and when we assure her that we were she suggests we try again but standing with our arms around her this time . I'm starting to enjoy this a bit . It was something new and exciting sharing my wife with another man even though it had only progressed to a few kisses but I kept wondering how far I would want it to go never mind how far Cindy would allow it to progress . I also knew that when Cindy had a few drinks in her she would argue that she was right even when anyone else could see she was wrong about anything that happened to catch her interest . This was starting to look like one of those times ,she wasn't about to admit she was wrong .
Tony whispered to me " Is you wife really wearing a garter belt ?" I lied softly " I don't know , maybe, I'll see if I can feel through her dress this kiss . Give it a shot yourself she will probably think its me . "
Tony gaped " You sure ,I don't want to make anyone uncomfortable ?" to which I just nodded before Tony approaches Cindy for the next kiss .
Cindy wraps her arms around Tony as they kiss and begins moving her hands around his back and shoulders . I realize she is trying to cheat . She trying to guess which one it is by feeling his body . Tony starts to return the favor by moving his hands to Cindy's waist then down her butt trying to feel the garter belt that I knew was there . I could also see from my vantage point that their crotches were pressed together . I knew Tony had to be as stiff as I was and I had the feeling that all this kissing was having an effect on my wife . When they finally broke the clinch Cindy had a self satisfying smile that told me she was going to guess wrong again. As I moved closer to my wife I noticed that her face was flush and I peeked at her cleavage which I knew gets the same rosy color when she is really turned on . In the low light I couldn't be certain but it appeared to be the same color as her face . I embraced my wife and kissed her deeply . I tried as best as possible to mimic Tony's hand movement from a moment earlier . I knew from a few slow dances earlier this evening that if I held Cindy close I could feel her lacy undergarments pressing through her dress.
During one of our dances she had described them as sexy and lacy and informed me that she was wearing a bra and panties with the garter and hose without a slip . I considered that Tony had just felt what I had felt . I also noticed that Cindy was softly grinding her pubic area against my hard cock . I wasn't sure if she even knew she was doing it . We broke the kiss and Cindy picked correctly this time but before Tony could say anything I held my hand up for him not to speak and then I told her she was wrong again . And then I added that she was cheating by using her hands to help her guess . She started to protest then made a complete about face saying " Well hands are okay to use because that is part of kissing and anyway the whole question was about sex . I use my hands during sex why wouldn't I be able to use them now ?"
Tony jumped in ," Are trying to get help from our clothes ? We could take them off but then you might be able to tell from a scar or mole or something ." I picked up that line of reasoning by saying " Cindy wouldn't be able to tell that way anyway ,look how long she's been trying this way and she 's missed every time ." Cindy still blindfolded stunned me by replying " Well then take 'em off then if you think I can't do it . I can't see you anyway if your naked or almost naked what difference is it going to make to me ?"
Tony and I went to the bedroom where Peg was still snoring loudly . I told Tony I wanted to see how far Cindy would go with this . I think he realized I was getting off on watching him and my wife so he just listened and nodded when I told him to try moving his hands up her dress . I told him I was going to go first to see if I could loosen her dress up . Cindy was standing when I walked across the room naked with a hard-on leading the way . We started kissing standing up and I pushed her onto the sofa . We kept kissing with our tongues exploring each other's mouths . My dick was pressing against her stocking clad thigh and I moved my hand down on the pretense of moving my member to a more comfortable position when I really wanted to unbutton the one buttoned that held the dress closed . I accomplished that then noticed a 2nd button on the inside of the dress . Cindy was running her fingers through my hair while we kissed and I moved my hand up her legs to see if she would stop me or not . She didn't .I was able to unfasten the last button and her dress slid open revealing her body in a matching red and black lace bra and panty set with a matching garter belt . Cindy looked sexy as hell with her flat stomach and 34 C chest ******* . She had one leg hooked over the top of the sofa while the other rested on the floor .She just lay there not saying a word as I left the sofa Tony took up where I left off . He kissed Cindy and his hands glided right to her tits .
Cindy moaned softly and I just stood watching from 3 feet away as Cindy's hand grasped Tony's prick . Tony took this as the greenest light he has ever seen . He moved his kiss from Cindy's lips to her nipples popping her tits out of the bras cups as he did so .
Tony moved one hand down and slid Cindy 's panties to the side ******** her glistening pussy . I knew from Cindy's moaning and wriggling that there was no going back at this point . Cindy was gasping " OHH that feels so good " Tony slid a finger into her cunt and Cindy jumped and shuddered with a small orgasm . Cindy guided Tony's dick to her pussy and Tony eagerly entered her as I watched . Cindy wrapped her legs around Tony's waist and locked her ankles together . It wasn't too much longer until she was using he feet to push Tony forward into her .
Cindy was commanding him to " FUCK ..ME... HARDER.." I started to jerk off and felt my self starting to come just as Tony started to thrust harder and Cindy was humping him back . I came all over Tony 's arm and Cindy's tits as Cindy arched her back and started to cum while Tony pulled out and came on my wife's stomach a moment after I did .
Tony climbed off my wife and stood up next to me . Cindy took the blindfold off and looked at both of us ,unsure .She came to me and kissed me softly saying Happy NEW Year then did the same to Tony . I got dressed and we left . Tony had promised me he wouldn't saying anything especially since he didn't want Peg to find out . The next day as we drove home Cindy told me how exciting it was for us to make love in front of a stranger and when I said I watched not Tony she looked at me in stunned silence . It then hit me that she thought it was me she was fucking while Tony stood watching . I told her how exciting I found it watching her having sex with another man . Cindy was silent the rest of the way home and I kept thinking this is going to be a big problem . When we arrived home no sooner did I close the door then Cindy was all over me . We made love right on the floor inside the front door . I think Cindy was trying to see if she could tell any difference between now and last night . She started to ask if I though she was a slut or a dirty whore as we made love . The dirty talk was turning me on and answered that I enjoyed last night tremendously . After we finished we talked about it further and I convinced her it was all right . She felt guilty for picking wrong and thought I was mad . I didn't tell her until much later on that I had pushed Tony towards her the whole time .
Cindy kept her head down and nervously drained her glass as she finished the story for Tina's benefit . Tina in an awestruck tone exclaimed " Wow ,is that smoking . What a night . And you husband didn't have a problem with it .You are so lucky ." Surprised Cindy replied " What do you mean ? " " Well your husband gets turned on watching you hump other guys ,you should make him happy . Think about it , You have this great marriage with all the stability and other things that go with it yet you can have this hedonistic secret life with your husband's complete blessing . You can have your pick of hunks down here and Ron won't be here for a few more days ,you should take advantage of it . I know I'm I am . I haven't had a good roll in the hay in a couple of months ."
" You think I should do it ?" , Cindy asked . " Women cheat on their spouses all the time . Its exciting , dangerous and you have permission . What happened after you got home that New Years ? " Cindy went on to describe how we both started to fantasize about having a threesome . We would go to a restaurant or even at the mall and when either one of us saw a guy that looked like a candidate we would start tell each other what the guy would do to Cindy and where it was happening ,a motel ,the backseat of the car ,things like that . Cindy and I would usually make love that night and we would flesh out the fantasy during the lovemaking . When Cindy once asked why I didn't join in when Tony was fucking her , I told her I was afraid she would freak out .
After this Tina prodded Cindy ," I bet the reason you were so hot while fucking Tony was that you weren't sure whether it was Ron or Tony . You at first thought it has to be Ron but then I bet deep in the back of your mind you kept thinking how decadent it would be if it was really Tony and not your hubby. " That set Cindy's mind whirling.
